top of page
Logo.png

Most Businesses Don't Need a New Website

Oct 27
3 min read

There's something slightly strange about being a website designer and telling businesses they probably don't need a new website, but it's something I genuinely believe. I've been designing and building websites for around 15 years, and one of the biggest things I've learned is that a new website isn't always the answer to a website problem.

Sometimes it's exactly what a business needs, but other times it's an expensive way of avoiding the real issue.

I regularly come across businesses that are unhappy with their websites. Perhaps they're not getting enough enquiries, the design feels dated or they've seen a competitor launch something new and suddenly feel their own website isn't good enough. The natural reaction is often to start thinking about a complete redesign, but before getting anywhere near that conversation, I think it's worth understanding what's actually wrong with the existing website and, more importantly, why it isn't doing what the business needs it to do.

A New Design Won't Automatically Fix an Old Problem

Imagine a business with a website that looks reasonably professional. The navigation works, the pages load properly and all the relevant information is there, but for some reason, people aren't making enquiries. The temptation is to change everything, introducing new colours, new layouts, fresh imagery and perhaps an entirely different structure. That might improve things, but what if the real problem is that visitors don't understand what the business actually offers?

Perhaps the wording is confusing, the most important information is buried halfway down a page or there's no clear reason for somebody to get in touch. You could spend thousands creating a beautiful new website and still have exactly the same problem. The only difference is that the problem now looks better.

Sometimes Small Changes Make a Big Difference

One of the things I really enjoy about website consultancy is looking at an existing website and spotting opportunities that the business owner might not have noticed. When you're looking at the same website every day, it's easy to become familiar with things that could actually be improved. Sometimes it takes somebody from outside the business to look at it with fresh eyes and ask a few simple questions.

It might be something as straightforward as changing a headline so people immediately understand what the business does, improving the navigation or replacing photography that no longer reflects the organisation. Sometimes the website has simply become cluttered after years of small changes, or the business has evolved while the website is still communicating who it was five years ago. None of these things automatically means the entire website needs replacing.

When Is a New Website the Right Decision?

There are absolutely times when starting again makes sense. The existing platform might no longer support what the business needs, the structure could have become so complicated that improving it would be more difficult than rebuilding it, or the business might have changed so significantly that it needs an entirely new approach. But I think that decision should come from properly understanding the problem rather than simply being frustrated with how the current website looks.

For me, website design has never been just about making something look attractive. It's about understanding what a business is trying to achieve, how its customers think and what needs to happen to bring those things together. Sometimes that involves a complete redesign, but sometimes it means making a handful of thoughtful changes to something that's already there.

Before commissioning a new website, it's worth asking whether you actually need a new website or whether you simply need somebody to explain why your current one isn't working as well as it could.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page